Recurring deposits are a safe and disciplined investment option that regular savers use to build their financial cushion. Banks offer interest rates ranging from 7.25% to 9% on RDs. These rates look attractive but RDs have limitations that most people miss. The most important drawbacks include zero tax benefits under Section 80C, penalties if you withdraw early, and fixed monthly commitments that don’t adjust to your changing financial situation.
RDs might not match inflation rates over their 6-month to 10-year terms. This is a big deal as it means that fixed deposits could be a better choice for many investors. The Tax Deducted at Source (TDS) on interest above ₹40,000 per year (₹50,000 for senior citizens) reduces your actual returns. This piece will address these disadvantages and help you decide if RDs match your financial goals. You might find other investment options that are a better fit for your needs.
What is a recurring deposit and how does it work?
Banks and India Post offer a specialized term deposit program called a recurring deposit. This program helps you save money through regular income. You can build your savings by making consistent monthly contributions over a set period.
Definition and basic structure
Recurring deposits work as a disciplined savings tool. You contribute a fixed sum each month instead of investing one large amount. The minimum deposit period starts from 6 months and can go up to 10 years. Your deposits mature on a specific date. You receive your principal amount along with accumulated interest.
Opening a recurring deposit account comes with simple eligibility rules:
- Anyone above 10 years old can open an account independently
- Children under 10 need a legal guardian
- Businesses, corporations, and government organizations can start RD accounts
Banks let you set up automatic transfers. Your specified amount moves from your savings to the RD account monthly. This ensures you never skip a deposit.
How interest is calculated
Banks compound interest quarterly on recurring deposits. They use a specific formula that tracks the growing balance as monthly deposits add up.
Banks calculate the maturity value using this formula: M = R[(1+i)^n-1]/[1-(1+i)^(-1/3)]
Where:
- M represents the maturity value
- R is your monthly installment amount
- n indicates the number of quarters
- I represents the annual interest rate divided by 400
To cite an instance, a monthly deposit of ₹5,000 at 7.5% interest per year for 60 months gives you about ₹62,478.46. This amount is a factor in each deposit earning interest for different periods. The first deposit earns interest for the whole tenure while the last one earns for just a month.
Difference between fixed deposit and recurring deposit
RDs and FDs are term deposits but differ in several ways:
Investment Pattern: FDs need one lump sum deposit. RDs work through regular monthly contributions.
Interest Calculation: FDs calculate interest on the entire principal from day one. RD interest uses the reducing balance method. Each monthly deposit counts as new, and interest grows as the principal increases.
Flexibility: FDs range from 7 days to 10 years. RDs start from 6 months.
Returns: FDs usually give higher overall returns since interest applies to the full amount from the start. RD returns to build up as you make monthly contributions.
Suitability: FDs work best with a lump sum investment. RDs suit those with regular income who want disciplined savings.
Both options share similar interest rates. Senior citizens get an extra 0.5% interest rate. You can also take loans against these deposits, though early withdrawals might lead to penalties.
Top disadvantages of recurring deposits
RDs provide stability and discipline, but they come with several drawbacks that could affect your money goals. You should know these important limitations before you lock your money away.
1. Lower returns compared to other investments
RDs give modest returns compared to market-linked investment options. The interest rates on RDs range between 6.5% and 8.5% annually. These rates are nowhere near what you might earn from equity mutual funds or stocks. This makes RDs a less attractive choice if you want to build wealth quickly.
The return gap becomes a bigger issue over time. Risk-averse investors might be happy with guaranteed but modest yields. But if you want to build substantial wealth, RDs might feel like “a slow boat to China”. The returns also don’t grow through compounding since interest is paid at maturity or quarterly instead of being reinvested.
2. No tax benefits under Section 80C
Bank recurring deposits have a big disadvantage – they’re not eligible for tax deductions under Section 80C of the Income Tax Act. This sets them apart from tax-saving tools like PPF, NSC, or specific fixed deposits that offer these benefits. Post office RDs with a 5-year term can qualify for tax benefits under Section 80C, but bank RDs don’t get this advantage.
The interest you earn on RDs is fully taxable and adds to your total income under “income from other sources”. Banks must deduct TDS at 10% if interest goes above ₹40,000 in a financial year (₹50,000 for senior citizens). This TDS rate jumps to 20% if you haven’t submitted your PAN card.
3. Penalty on premature withdrawal
RDs lock in your money for a set period, and early access costs you. Most banks charge 0.5% to 1% for early withdrawals, based on how long until maturity. The interest rate also drops on early closure – you’ll get either the rate from your deposit date for the actual period or the contracted rate, whichever is lower.
Banks usually allow just one early withdrawal before maturity, and you must take out all your money at once. If you close your RD within its first month, you might only get your principal back with no interest. Post office RDs are even stricter – you can’t withdraw early until three years have passed.
4. Fixed monthly commitment
RDs need you to stick to monthly deposit schedules. You must put in the same amount each month throughout the term, regardless of your financial situation. Missing payments could lead to penalties or account closure if you skip deposits for more than three months.
You can’t change your deposit amounts either. Unlike other investment options that let you adjust your contributions, RDs keep you locked into one amount. This makes them tough to manage when your income changes or during money emergencies.
5. Inflation risk over long tenure
RDs face a hidden risk from inflation that many people overlook. Your money loses real buying power when inflation rates exceed your RD interest rate. To name just one example, an RD offering 8.25% returns with 10% inflation means your ₹108,250 might buy less than what ₹98,000 could have bought before.
Long-term RDs face this inflation risk even more. Since their returns stay fixed, they can’t keep up with rising inflation, which eats into your savings. A simple example shows that 5% returns with 6% inflation leaves you with negative 1% real returns. High inflation periods hit RDs hard because their fixed interest structure can’t take advantage of rising rates in the broader economy.
Hidden limitations you might overlook
Recurring deposits have several hidden limitations beyond the obvious drawbacks. These restrictions can affect your financial flexibility and long-term goals if you don’t think them over before opening an account.
Lack of flexibility in deposit amount
The biggest drawback of recurring deposits is that you can’t change your monthly contribution amount. The deposit amount you choose when opening the account stays fixed for the entire period. If your income goes up or you get a bonus, you can’t add these extra funds to your existing RD. The minimum amount starts at ₹1,000, and you can only increase it in multiples of ₹100 when you first set up the account.
This rigid structure creates problems during financial emergencies or when your income changes. Unlike other investment options, RDs don’t adapt to your changing financial situation. Whether you’re looking at SBI, HDFC, or ICICI, all banks follow these strict rules about deposit amounts.
No partial withdrawal allowed
Banks also don’t let you make partial withdrawals from your RD account before it matures. The banking policy clearly states: “Sorry, currently a Recurring Deposit cannot be withdrawn partially”.
You can only make one early withdrawal if you need money urgently, and you must take out all your accumulated funds. Some banks add extra rules – you can only withdraw early after your RD account has been active for a year with at least 12 monthly deposits.
Limited wealth accumulation potential
RDs limit your ability to build wealth compared to other investment options. Their low-risk, low-return nature makes them poor tools to accumulate substantial wealth. Aggressive savers might find RDs to be “a slow boat to China”.
This becomes clear when you compare RDs with fixed deposits or market-linked investments. RDs work well for short-term goals or emergency funds but fall short for long-term wealth creation.
The modest returns, combined with tax implications and inflation that we discussed earlier, reduce your potential to build wealth over time through RDs.
Recurring deposit vs fixed deposit: which is better?
Choosing between recurring deposits and fixed deposits comes down to your financial situation and goals. Each type serves different purposes and needs. Neither option is universally better than the other.
When to choose RD over FD
Recurring deposits work best if you have a regular income and prefer to build savings through monthly contributions instead of a lump sum investment. RDs provide the structure you need to prepare for short to medium-term goals like a vacation or car down payment. These deposits are perfect if you want a disciplined approach to saving without much upfront capital.
RDs attract first-time savers and people with limited investment knowledge because they’re straightforward and need smaller original commitments. Homemakers, students, and freelancers who might not have large sums to invest at once find RDs especially helpful.
Interest rate comparison
Fixed deposits usually give slightly higher interest rates than recurring deposits. Banks receive the entire investment amount upfront with FDs, while RDs bring money in installments over time.
FDs earn interest on the entire principal from day one. RDs calculate interest on the growing balance as monthly deposits add up. This key difference means that even with similar interest rates, FDs tend to give higher effective returns than RDs.
Liquidity and withdrawal rules
You can withdraw money early from both investment types, though banks charge different penalties. Fixed deposits give you more liquidity since you can make partial withdrawals. This lets you access some funds while keeping the rest invested.
RDs don’t usually allow partial withdrawals—you need to close the account completely to get your money. On top of that, some banks need a minimum lock-in period before they let you withdraw from RDs.
Fixed deposits offer extra flexibility through loans—banks often give loans up to 90% of the FD value. This feature adds a layer of liquidity that recurring deposits don’t always have, which makes FDs more versatile during financial emergencies.
Bank-specific variations and charges
Major banks in India provide recurring deposits with different terms, penalties, and interest rates. These differences play a crucial role when you select the best option that matches your financial goals.
What is recurring deposit in SBI, HDFC, ICICI
India’s leading banks offer recurring deposit products with unique features and returns. SBI lets you start with just ₹100 monthly and offers interest rates between 6.80% and 7.00% for regular citizens. Senior citizens get better rates from 7.30% to 7.50%. HDFC Bank needs a higher starting amount of ₹1,000, which you can increase in multiples of ₹100 up to ₹1,99,99,900 monthly. The bank gives interest rates from 4.50% to 7.10% for regular customers, while senior citizens receive 5.00% to 7.75%. ICICI Bank sets its rates between 4.75% and 7.10% for general citizens and 5.25% to 7.60% for seniors. You can choose terms ranging from 6 months to 10 years.
Post office recurring deposit vs bank RD
Post Office recurring deposits give a 6.7% interest rate right now. The biggest difference lies in safety. Post Office RDs come with zero risk because the Government of India backs them fully. Bank deposits, however, have insurance only up to ₹5 lakh. Post Offices stick to a fixed 5-year term, but banks let you pick anything from 6 months to 10 years. The rules about taking money out early also differ. You can close a Post Office RD after 3 years, but you’ll get only savings account rates. Banks are more flexible with early withdrawals but charge penalties. Post Office RDs also let you take loans up to 50% of your balance after a year. Banks offer bigger loans – up to 90% of your deposit.
Fees and penalties across banks
Banks charge early withdrawal penalties between 0.5% and 1% of your deposit amount. To cite an instance, see ICICI Bank’s penalty structure – 0.50% for deposits under 1 year, 1.00% for 1-5 years, and 1.00% to 1.50% when deposits cross 5 years. Late payments cost you monthly interest at ₹12 per ₹1,000, and banks count partial months as full ones. Most banks have a lock-in period of one to three months. You might not get any interest if you withdraw during this time. Many banks also require you to close the entire account to access your money – partial withdrawals aren’t allowed.
Conclusion
RDs provide a well-laid-out path to save money with discipline, but they have major limitations you need to think over. Our analysis shows RDs don’t match up to market-linked investments in returns. They also lack the tax benefits you get from PPF or 5-year tax-saving FDs. The fixed monthly payments make them rigid and might not work when your finances fluctuate.
The low interest rates on RDs barely keep up with inflation, which means your money loses value as time passes. You’ll face penalties if you need to withdraw early, and access to your funds becomes restricted during emergencies. FDs are better than RDs – they give higher returns and more flexibility through partial withdrawals and loan options.
Your bank’s specific terms will shape your investment decision. SBI, HDFC, and ICICI have competitive rates, while Post Office RDs give you government security but stricter withdrawal rules. Take time to evaluate your financial goals, steady income, and investment timeline before you start an RD. These deposits work well to save for short-term goals or build an emergency fund. But to create substantial wealth over time, you should look at diverse investment options beyond RDs. The best investment strategy matches your financial situation rather than using a standard approach.
FAQs
Q1. What are the main drawbacks of recurring deposits? Recurring deposits offer lower returns compared to market-linked investments, lack tax benefits under Section 80C, and impose penalties for premature withdrawals. They also require fixed monthly commitments and may not keep pace with inflation over long tenures.
Q2. How do recurring deposits compare to fixed deposits? While both offer stable returns, fixed deposits typically provide slightly higher interest rates and more flexibility. FDs allow for lump-sum investments and often permit partial withdrawals, whereas RDs require regular monthly contributions and usually don’t allow partial access to funds before maturity.
Q3. What happens to a recurring deposit after it matures? Upon maturity, you receive the total amount of your invested capital along with the accumulated interest. The bank typically credits this sum to your linked savings account or issues a demand draft, depending on your instructions.
Q4. Are recurring deposits a good investment option? Recurring deposits can be suitable for short-term financial goals and disciplined saving, especially for those with regular income. However, they may not be ideal for long-term wealth creation due to their modest returns and lack of tax benefits compared to other investment options.
Q5. How do bank-specific variations affect recurring deposits? Different banks offer varying interest rates, minimum deposit amounts, and tenure options for recurring deposits. For example, SBI, HDFC, and ICICI Bank have different rate structures and minimum deposit requirements. Additionally, penalties for premature withdrawals and late payments can vary across banks, affecting the overall returns and flexibility of the investment.
Leave a Reply